Edgewonk is the statistician trading journal built for traders who obsess over R-multiples and edge ratios. Stonk Journal is the opposite: stripped-down, fast, and aimed at traders who want to log and see basic P&L. Neither has AI. Neither syncs brokers automatically. If you want modern AI insights without CSV hassle, both fall short.
Side by side
| Feature | SuperTrader | Edgewonk | Stonk Journal |
|---|---|---|---|
| Starting price | $0 / mo | $169 one-time | $19/mo |
| Free plan | Free forever | None | None |
| Broker integrations | 1,000+ | CSV only | Limited CSV |
| AI insights | AI coach + agents | None | None |
| Mobile app | iOS and Android | Web only | Web only |
| Mood tracking | Included | None | None |
| Backtesting engine | Full | None | None |
Our verdict
Between Edgewonk and Stonk Journal: Edgewonk edges ahead for serious analysts. Its statistical depth — R-multiples, setup tagging, psychological modules — makes it the stronger analytical tool for traders who study every trade in detail.
Neither Edgewonk nor Stonk Journal offer real-time AI coaching during your session. Post-trade review is useful, but only if you spot the patterns that keep repeating. SuperTrader's AI Agents (Pro) check your trades daily and flag them for you — and it starts free, no credit card required.
Neither is your best option
SuperTrader vs Competitors
More Comparisons